Papa Dave's Pizzeria

Discover delicious thin-crust pizza at Papa Dave's Pizzeria in Hurley, WI. Enjoy hot, gluten-free options, friendly staff, and a cozy dining experience. Call +1 715-208-0322 for more!

Welcome to Papa Dave's Pizzeria

Taste the Difference.

Papa Dave's Pizzeria
Papa Dave's Pizzeria
Papa Dave's Pizzeria
Papa Dave's Pizzeria

Nestled at 410 Silver St in Hurley, Wisconsin, Papa Dave's Pizzeria serves up a slice of comfort with each pizza. This cozy spot is known for its cash-only policy, ensuring you get the best value for your meal without the fees of card transactions. Patrons rave about the thin crust, which is both crispy and flavorful, making every bite a treat.

Whether you’re here for a quick meal or a leisurely dining experience, the genuine warmth of the staff shines through, creating an inviting atmosphere perfect for families, friends, or a casual date night. With plenty of specialty pies and gluten-free options available, Papa Dave’s caters to a variety of tastes and dietary needs.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

410 Silver St, Hurley, WI 54534, United States

Phone

+1 715-208-0322

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Papa Dave's Pizzeria
Papa Dave's Pizzeria
Papa Dave's Pizzeria
Papa Dave's Pizzeria

Established to bring joy through delicious pizza, Papa Dave's Pizzeria embodies the spirit of community in Hurley, WI. The menu features an array of 15 mouthwatering items, with a particular emphasis on specialty pizzas. The Chicken Alfredo pizza stands out with its creamy sauce and tender chicken, making it a must-try. Other highly recommended options include the Pulled Pork pizza and the Veggie pizza, which caters to vegetarian preferences without compromising on flavor.

The commitment to serve high-quality ingredients shines through in each dish, ensuring every patron leaves satisfied.

The welcoming vibe resonates with both locals and visitors alike, creating a space where conversations flourish and connections are made. The decor reflects a casual yet charming ambiance, with nods to the community's love for pizza. The dining room, though small, fosters a sense of togetherness—perfect for sharing a meal with loved ones.

Papa Dave's is more than just a restaurant; it's a gathering place.

Events and community gatherings often take place here, making it an integral part of the Hurley social scene. This commitment to community extends beyond just serving food; it involves actively participating in local events and supporting neighborhood initiatives. Regulars often share stories of how Papa Dave's feels like an extended family, where everyone knows each other's names. This strong community connection is what sets Papa Dave's apart from typical pizzerias.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday12-8 PM
  • MondayClosed
  • TuesdayClosed
  • WednesdayClosed
  • Thursday4-8 PM
  • Friday4-8 PM
  • Saturday12-8 PM

Papa Dave's packs a punch in its compact dining room, offering an intimate setting that keeps diners returning. Known for its passionate staff, the service remains consistently positive, making each visit pleasant. The pizzeria specializes in unique pizza varieties, including Chicken Alfredo, BBQ Chicken, and Buffalo Chicken, each crafted to perfection. A highlight for many is the restaurant's famous pizza fry, a local favorite that’s always a crowd-pleaser. Alongside pizza, fresh salads like Caesar and Side Salad provide a refreshing accompaniment.

Local beer options such as Bells Two Hearted IPA and New Glarus Spotted Cow allow you to pair your meal with regional favorites. The quick wait time adds to the convenience, ensuring that even during busy hours, the hot pizza arrives promptly.

Papa Dave's Pizzeria

The exterior of Papa Dave's welcomes visitors with a quaint facade that reflects its friendly nature. Located in a vibrant neighborhood, the pizzeria catches the eye with colorful signage and inviting decor that hints at the delicious flavors inside. Out front, tables during warmer months allow diners to experience Hurley's small-town charm while indulging in a slice or two. The atmosphere inside buzzes with laughter and chatter, making it an ideal spot for casual gatherings. The overall vibe is warm and welcoming, encouraging guests to relax and enjoy their meals amidst the cheerful environment.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

AMAZING!!!!!! We came here because we could smell it from a block away, turns out it was closed... But he told us that the oven was still warm and he would cook us up one. Turns out it's some of the best pizza I've ever had. This 2nd generation pizza shop know what he's doing and he's damn good at it!! I will definitely be coming back here when I'm in town next year.

B
Ben D.

Dave's is quite honestly the best "bar" style pizza you'll ever have. Crust is a perfect mixture of fluffy and crunchy. Not to mention Dave and his staff are super friendly and accommodating. Can't wait to come back and get more!

J
Jeremiah F.

On our visit from the Twin Cities, we stopped by Papa Dave's for lunch and we were very impressed with the quality of the food. The pizza and pizza fry were perfect in every way. We tried their Gnocchi with meatballs special and it was the real deal. We love their home-made bread, too. The amazing food, friendly service and reasonable prices made this the best restaurant in town!

C
Conrad N.

Five stars all the way!!! Excellent food both times I've eaten from there. I can see Papa Dave's pizzeria being here for a very very long time with their positive and friendly staff that you can see they just have a passion for making pizza and not just a plain jane pizza but they are coming out new a different pizzas that you don't see elsewhere. With a very clean place and the decor that puts the icing on top. There's no doubt that this great place to bring your family and friends or even a great place to bring a date. Congratulations Papa Dave's pizzeria I can't wait to see all the pizzas you come out with.

A
Amy F.

Popped in on a Sunday had some of the best pizza! We got a deluxe, pickle pizza fries, and papa bake. Would highly recommend and will be stopping by when I'm close!

A
Anthony

Looking for places that my husband can eat is tough, especially in smaller towns. Not only does this place have great pizza, they also have a great gluten free cauliflower crust. So crispy. So good. Tiny, so plan accordingly.

K
Kim B.